Top 5 Best Toys For Border Collies (2021 Review): All Work No Play Makes Doggo A Dull Pup

On the hunt for the best Border Collie toys?

You’ve come to the right place!

In this Digdoggy.com guide, you’ll learn:

  • The top 5 toys for Border Collies
  • Benefits of dog toys for Border Collies
  • What toys you should skip
  • And much more!

what are the best border collie toys? featured image

In a hurry? Right below is a rundown of our top picks. That said, you can read our in-depth reviews for each product later on in this post. 

ImageProduct
digital-business-prep-table__image
ChuckIt! Flying Squirrel
  • irregular flight pattern and appearance intrigue dogs
  • lightweight and buoyant
  • glows in the dark
  • irregular flight pattern and appearance intrigue dogs
  • lightweight and buoyant
  • glows in the dark
View on Amazon
digital-business-prep-table__image
ChuckIt! Dog Ball Launcher + Ball
  • improves your throwing speed
  • eliminates the need to bend and pick up filthy balls
  • Strong & durable
  • improves your throwing speed
  • eliminates the need to bend and pick up filthy balls
  • Strong & durable
View on Amazon
digital-business-prep-table__image
ELOPAW Dog Chew Tug-Of-War Toy
  • Powerful suction and durable cord
  • Powerful suction and durable cord
  • Made of non-toxic materials
  • Powerful suction and durable cord
  • Powerful suction and durable cord
  • Made of non-toxic materials
View on Amazon
digital-business-prep-table__image
TRIXIE Interactive Treat Puzzle Game
  • Offers beginner, intermediate, and expert levels to challenge puppies and adult dogs
  • Provides mental stimulation
  • can be used for dogs & cats too
  • Offers beginner, intermediate, and expert levels to challenge puppies and adult dogs
  • Provides mental stimulation
  • can be used for dogs & cats too
View on Amazon
digital-business-prep-table__image
NOUGAT Squeaky Dog Toy for Aggressive Chewers
  • Made with industrial-strength natural rubber that is softer than nylon chews, but more robust than a Kong
  • FDA-approved quality construction
  • Features a milky scent and flavor
  • Made with industrial-strength natural rubber that is softer than nylon chews, but more robust than a Kong
  • FDA-approved quality construction
  • Features a milky scent and flavor
View on Amazon

Our Overall #1 Rated Pick

Updated On August 12, 2021

There’s no doubt that the ChuckIt flying squirrel will quickly become your Border Collies favorite toy. 

Whilst this boasts a simple design, the fun that it brings far exceeds simplicity, as you can use this toy on land or in water (yes it floats), and it is available in multiple sizes to suit different sized dogs (10-11inches being a great fit for Collies). 

Our reason for choosing this toy to be the no1 pick is down to the fact that it’s relatively low priced, long-lasting, and encourages fun outdoor activities that will provide both you and your Border Collie high levels of mental and physical stimulation. 

Over time, you may notice the toy start to flatten, which is totally fine as it tends to perform better in the wind when like this. 

Check out a video review to see how it shapes up (no pun intended).

What's In This Guide?

      Top 5 Best Toys For Border Collies

      In a hurry? Check out our top 5 toys for your Collie. Keep reading to discover more about our top picks.

      1. ChuckIt! Flying Squirrel
      2. ChuckIt! Dog Ball Launcher + Ball
      3. ELOPAW Dog Chew Tug-Of-War Toy
      4. TRIXIE Interactive Treat Puzzle Game
      5. NOUGAT Squeaky Dog Toy for Aggressive Chewers

      Is It Good For Border Collies To Play With Toys?

      Yes! Toys are a necessity to the well-being of our pets, especially if you have a smart and active dog, which in your case is true. But here’s why dog toys are so important:

      🐻🏀🎲 Provides Intellectual Stimulation

      Wild canines have a myriad of ways to amuse themselves. Domestic dogs, on the other hand, don’t have access to the kind of natural entertainment you’ll find in the wild. Without such thrills in the backyard, your canine buddy can get bored and cranky way too fast.

      The right toys, however, bring our pets the mental workout they need. For adult dogs, playing mentally stimulating games is the equivalent of us humans, solving a crossword puzzle or Rubik’s cube. It exercises Doggo’s noggin!

      On top of this, it tires out your pooch a lot quicker than a short walk. Helping your Border Collie to get a good night’s sleep means working both brain and body. And as the adage goes, “A tired dog is a happy dog!”

       

      🐻🏀🎲 Builds Independence And Staves Off Bad Behaviors

      Border Collies kept as pets in houses and apartments are often considered “Velcro dogs.” These pampered pooches tend to get more clingy to their parents in comparison to country dogs that work in ranches or farms. 

      Don’t get me wrong…Toys should not replace quality time with your pooch, but it isn’t possible to be with them all the time due to work and other life commitments.

      So…The solution? Enrichment toys. These playthings promote natural behaviors, such as foraging and exploration to name a few. Which will help your pooch to enjoy short moments of being alone. 

      In turn, keeping your dog stimulated will encourage good sleep, good behavior, and a general happy healthy existence. 

      With toys that help mitigate a dog’s loneliness, your dog is unlikely to exhibit behavioral issues, such as mindless chewing and excessive barking.

      Read Also: >> What are the best overall dog toys for all breeds? 

       

      🐻🏀🎲  Provides A Fair Amount Of Distraction

      You might be the apple of Doggo’s eyes, but you won’t get anything done if your pooch keeps an eye on you 24/7. A simple yet effective solution for you to earn a moment of peace and privacy is to give Doggo something fun to do. 

      A good bout of mental or physical activity will tire him or her out and cause them to lose interest in following you around.

      quick fact about border collies participating in the World Canine Disc Championship as far back as the 1980's

      What Type Of Toys Do Border Collies Like?

      When it comes to purchasing dog toys, you’ll have to mull over what’s safe and beneficial for your pet. Unlike cats, our canine companions often love to play rough and they can be a little bit choosy to boot. 

      This task is not made any simpler if you have a Border Collie ─ a breed with exceptional intelligence and a seemingly unending reservoir of energy.

      So what are good Border Collie toys? The best toys for Border Collies are those that involve elements that will test as well as satisfy the breed’s intellect and athleticism, such as:

      • Puzzle toys: These toys are great when you’re away or busy. Puzzle toys have flaps, levers, and buttons that Doggo has to use to open the compartments where the treats are kept. These toys also tend to have varying difficulties. Given the intellect of the Border Collie, you may skip level 1 puzzles.
      • Tug toys: These toys come in different designs. Some models have suction cups so that your pooch can continue to play tug-of-war for hours.
      • Toys for fetch: Toys made for fetching include discs, balls, and tools that act as a slingshot of sorts so you can send the object flying a long way without much trouble. Automated ball throwers are now available in the market but unless you are physically challenged, it’s always better to remain hands-on and play with your pooch.  

      Border Collies are notable for developing destructive chewing behaviors if their owners fail to provide them with healthy outlets around the house. Since not all dog toys in the market are worth buying for a Border Collie, it’s wise to read this article before you part ways with your money.

      Read Also: >> How do you provide the most mental stimulation to your Border Collie?

      How Do you Keep your Border Collie Entertained?

      Don’t underestimate the combined intelligence and athleticism of the Border Collie. If you have a spacious backyard, you can construct an agility course for your sporty canine. I’m sure you wouldn’t want your Border Collie’s incredible potential to go to waste! There are kits available but you may also do some DIY if you have the skills.

      Below is a quick video sharing a few unique ways of keeping your Border Collie occupied! 

      What Should You Avoid when buying toys for a Border Collie?

      Tennis Balls

      Tennis balls have synthetic fibers that can hold fine sand and gravel. This surface is like an emery board that files your dog’s teeth. Substitute a tennis ball with Chuckit! Ultra Ball; it doesn’t have an abrasive surface nor does it hold dirt.

      Plastic Chew Toys With Questionable Durability

      Low-quality plastic chews are dangerous; they are a cinch for any dog to tear apart. Your pooch might swallow bits of plastic that could lead to digestive upset or worse, intestinal obstruction. Not to mention, the terrible chemical smells. 

      Ensure you choose brands that have built impressive reputations and amassed positive customer feedback.

      Chew Bones That Could Splinter

      You’ll also need to be extra cautious with chew bones. 

      Aggressive chewers tend to gnaw so hard; they will continue to chew until their gums bleed. To stay on the safe side, you’ll want to stick to bully sticks and other edible chews.

      Unfortunately with chews, they get more expensive the more natural they get. If your Border Collie can go through an edible chew for a few hours, then expect to pay a hefty amount of money on chews alone.

      Squeaky Stuffed Animals

      Dogs love stuffed animals but plush toys with a squeaker are an invitation for canines to play doggie surgeon. Remember, the Border Collie is a curious, intelligent breed; it is likely Doggo will see the squeaker as the puzzle’s endgame.

      Read Also: >> How much exercise should you give your Border Collie? 

      Our Review Of The Best Toys For Puppy to Adult Border Collies

      Pick #1: ChuckIt! Flying Squirrel

      Believe me when I say the ChuckIt! Flying Squirrel is going to be one of the best investments you’ll ever make throughout your pet parenting life! This little neon squirrel will soar a lot better than standard discs.

      The only issue about the Flying Squirrel is that it takes some time to get used to it.

      Throwing the toy for the first time might make you feel like you have the motor skills of a 50-year old divorcee who failed PE back in high school. Eventually, you’ll learn the ropes and with some newly acquired skills, you can make it glide long distances.

      The Flying Squirrel is also perfect if you are planning to use it in the water because it floats. The curved sides allow dogs to catch it with ease and the edges of the toy glow in the dark, so it’s definitely a breeze to spot. Add to this is the fact that dogs can visually identify the colors blue and orange.

      This toy is rugged and tough and meant to withstand strong bites. Regardless, you should not leave the toy alone with your Border Collie. The Flying Squirrel is a throw-and-retrieve toy. Leaving your pooch to play on their own with this toy may result in destruction, so it’s always recommended you play along too.

      That said if your dog does end up literally “loving it to bits,” you can always replace it without breaking the bank. 

      Pros

      Cons

      Pick #2: ChuckIt! Dog Ball Launcher

      The classic game of fetch is incontestably one of the best games you can engage in with your Border Collie.

      That said, you’ll most likely grow too tired before your dog decides to call it a day.

      So, to avoid turning this into a solo project, you’ll need the help of Chuckit! Dog Ball Launcher.

      As you might have guessed, it isn’t a toy per se, but more of a tool that serves as an extended arm. 

      With this launcher, you can throw a ball further with less energy spent, and therefore, you can play longer with your canine buddy. All you have to do is put the cup around the ball and lock it into place. You won’t have to bend and pick up the ball.

      This product goes hand in hand with a medium-sized Chuckit! Ultra Ball

      You might be thinking to yourself, “Why not get an old tennis ball?” The waterproof Ultra Ball offers a lot more durability and bounces than a dirt-cheap ball.

      Pros

      Cons

      Pick #3: ELOPAW Dog Chew Tug-Of-War Toy

      This multidimensional toy by ELOPAW is a surefire way to beat canine boredom. It is a ball, a Kong-like chew toy, and a tug-of-war rope rolled into one!

      There is a whistle inside the ball that squeaks to grab Doggo’s attention.

      The ELOPAW Dog Chew Tug-Of-War Toy comes equipped with double suction cups that you can attach to any smooth surface. Each suction cup can withstand 200 pounds of pulling force.

      If you have the cups securely fitted onto the floor, then they will not come up. Your pooch can play tug-of-war for as long as he wants to.

      Moreover, you can tuck in tasty treats inside the textured rubber ball. Doggo will exercise his noggin as he tries to figure out how to take them out through the slits.

      Made with food-grade thermoplastic rubber, it is flexible enough for dogs to gnaw yet sturdy enough not to fall apart. Your collie can try to end the ball’s life while you enjoy dinner or watch Netflix in peace.

      The only improvement I would suggest is to give the rope more length and elasticity so the ball would bounce back, thus creating a more exhaustive and exciting play.

      Nevertheless, you can still expect its current design to suck in your collie’s excessive energy, clean its teeth, and tickle its genius brain.

      Pros

      Cons

      Pick #4: TRIXIE Interactive Treat Puzzle Game Level 2

      TRIXIE is notable for its interactive puzzle games that start with level one and go all the way up to level three.

      The photo here shows the TRIXIE Interactive Treat Puzzle level two. The level one puzzle might not offer much of a challenge for a Border Collie, but you should get it for a pup.

      Now the question: will a Border Collie get bored after mastering it?

      As you may already know, Border Collies are nature’s A students, so it would be best to get level two and level three of this game, so you can alternate the puzzles and spice things up!

      This game is also perfect for visually impaired dogs and seniors.

      Pros

      Cons

      Pick #5: NOUGAT Squeaky Dog Toy for Aggressive Chewers

      Many chew toys will last a minute, some a few days, but the Nougat Squeaky Dog Toy will not go down that easily!

      You’ll be impressed by the quality of this toy, as it can withstand the bite force of a 110-pound canine.

      This product has received FDA certification; rest assured it doesn’t contain harmful chemicals. The toy, however, gives off a milky scent to entice your pooch.

      Regardless of the shape you choose ━ be it crocodile, grenade, or eagle ━ it offers the same benefits. Aside from relieving anxiety and boredom, it effectively cleans teeth to keep tartar and plaque growth at bay.

      If Doggo doesn’t like his teeth brushed, you can squeeze flavored toothpaste along the grooves. The toy also has a squeaker inside, which adds to the fun of watching your pooch play and react to the sound.

      On a positive note, the toy doesn’t make frequent noise so it suits anyone working at home.

      Pros

      Cons

      Our Top Pick: ChuckIt! Flying Squirrel

      Our top pick is the ChuckIt flying squirrel as it is the most versatile yet simple toy that brings the most fun over long periods of time. 

      You can expect this toy to last you years on end and the fun to continue just too, as long as you’ll find the more you play the better you become in throwing.  

      Throwing the toy for the first time might make you feel like you have the motor skills of a 50-year old divorcee who failed PE back in high school.

      However, you’ll eventually learn the ropes and with some newly acquired skills, you can make it glide long distances.

      The curved sides allow dogs to catch it with ease and the edges of the toy glow in the dark, so it’s definitely a breeze to spot. Add to this is the fact that dogs can visually identify the colors blue and orange.

      This toy is rugged and tough and meant to withstand strong bites. Regardless, you should not leave the toy alone with your Border Collie. The Flying Squirrel is a throw-and-retrieve toy.

      The Flying Squirrel is also perfect if you are planning to use it in the water because it floats. That said if your dog does end up “loving it to bits,” you can always replace it without breaking the bank. 

      What more could you ask for? Overall, this is a fantastic option when buying a toy for a Border Collie. 

      Read Also: >> What are the best games to play with your Border Collie?

      Conclusion

      Pet boredom is a big problem given the indoor lifestyle that many Border Collies have today. So it is important to provide your pet a set of toys to tickle its intelligent mind and deplete excess energy.

      While there is an immense selection in the market, you’ll never go wrong if you try the suggestions above. Most importantly, please find time to spend a few hours with your pooch each day.

      Leaving your pooch to play on their own with this toy may result in destruction, so it’s always recommended you play along too.

      Lara Writes

      Lara Writes

      Lara, a.k.a Alpha Mama, is a great dancer and belter singer, although the world tells her otherwise. However, her greatest pleasure is working with animals. If the Alpha Mama is not being delusional, she manages to create informative articles and clear-cut buying guides. She also likes to share her personal experiences that may ignite your soul or possibly change your life!

      Learn More About Pet Care​

      Raising a pup shouldn’t at all be hard. Check out some of these other helpful guides to help you become an even better pet parent! 

      Lara Writes

      Lara Writes

      Lara, a.k.a Alpha Mama, is a great dancer and belter singer, although the world tells her otherwise. However, her greatest pleasure is working with animals. If the Alpha Mama is not being delusional, she manages to create informative articles and clear-cut buying guides. She also likes to share her personal experiences that may ignite your soul or possibly change your life!

      About Dig Doggy

      DigDoggy® is a free resource for dog owners, with everything from expert product reviews to trusted pet care advice.

      All of our reviews and recommendations are based on unbiased research by our editorial team. Read more about us.

      Recently Published Guides